You sign the closing papers. The previous owner hands you a small ziplock bag with four keys. They say something like “I think these are all of them.” You smile, take the keys, and start moving boxes.
That ziplock is the problem. Rekeying solves it.
Whoever lived in that house before you handed keys to dog walkers, contractors, neighbors, the kid who mowed the lawn, a real estate stager, the cleaner. Some of those keys came back. Most didn’t. Nobody can tell you for sure who still has access to your new home, and the previous owner usually doesn’t know either. They mean well. They just lost track years ago.
This is why rekeying is the first call most homeowners in Montgomery County and Prince George’s County should make after closing. Not the painters. The locksmith.
What rekeying actually does
A lock has a set of small spring-loaded pins inside the cylinder. Each pin sits at a specific height matched to a specific key. When you slide the right key in, the pins line up and the cylinder turns. When you slide a wrong key in, they don’t.
Rekeying means a locksmith pulls the cylinder out of your existing lock, swaps the pin configuration for a new one, and cuts a new key to match. Same lock. Same handle. Same finish. Any key that used to open it goes dead.
The deadbolt on the front door, the lock on the back patio slider, the bolt on the basement walkout, the cylinder on the garage side door. All of them can be set to a single new key in one visit. You stop carrying a ring of mystery keys and start carrying one.
What the previous owner doesn’t actually know
People underestimate how many copies of a house key float around over the years. A house in Bethesda or Silver Spring that’s been owned by one family for fifteen years has had keys handed to housekeepers, in-laws, a string of teenagers’ friends, the home health aide who came for grandpa, the guy who refinished the floors, a neighbor who watered plants during vacations.
A house in Hyattsville or Laurel that’s been a rental for the last decade has had keys cut and recut for every tenant turnover. Property managers try. They don’t always succeed. Old keys sit in junk drawers and toolboxes long after the people who held them have moved away.
The seller signs an affidavit at closing saying they’ve given you all the keys. They believe it when they sign it. They’re often wrong without knowing it.
You don’t need to be paranoid about this. You just need to be done with it. Rekeying is the line where you stop inheriting other people’s key history.
When rekeying is the right call. When it isn’t.
Most front doors in Montgomery and Prince George’s County use Grade 2 or Grade 3 residential deadbolts from a handful of major brands. If the lock is in good shape, turns smoothly, and the strike plate is solid, rekeying handles the situation. There’s no reason to throw away working hardware.
A few cases where rekeying alone isn’t enough:
- The lock is older than the house’s last major renovation and feels loose, sticky, or stiff. Internal parts wear out. A locksmith pulling the cylinder will see this and tell you straight.
- The strike plate is held in by short screws and the door jamb shows splits or shimming. The lock is fine. The door isn’t. You want longer screws into framing and probably a reinforced strike.
- A back door has a builder-grade lock the previous owner never upgraded. Common in newer construction in places like Germantown, Bowie, Clarksburg, and Upper Marlboro. The cylinder isn’t worth rekeying because the whole assembly is the weak point.
- The exterior door has a smart lock the previous owner registered to their phone. Rekeying does nothing here. You need a factory reset, a fresh account setup, and an audit of who was on the old account.
A good locksmith looks at every door and tells you which ones need rekeying, which need replacement, and which need a hardware upgrade. The walk-through itself is short. The answer is often a mix.
Maryland houses have their own quirks
A 1940s brick rancher in Takoma Park has very different door hardware than a 2018 townhouse near Clarksburg. Both of them need to be secure. Neither needs the same approach.
Older homes in Chevy Chase, Bethesda, Hyattsville, and parts of College Park were built with mortise locks. These sit inside a pocket carved into the door itself rather than bolting onto the surface. They’re often beautiful, often original to the house, and almost always rekeyable. People assume they need to be replaced because they look unusual. They usually don’t.
Mid-century homes in Wheaton, Aspen Hill, Lanham, and Adelphi tend to have standard cylindrical locks. Easy to rekey. Frequently the right candidate for an upgrade to a higher security cylinder if you want one.
Newer construction across Germantown, Bowie, Laurel, and Upper Marlboro often ships with builder-grade hardware that was specified by cost rather than security rating. Rekeying buys you control of the keys. A hardware swap on the front and back doors usually makes more sense than rekeying alone in these cases.
There’s also humidity. Maryland summers swell wood doors and shift door alignment. A deadbolt that turned smoothly in April starts catching in August. If a lock is already struggling against a swollen frame, rekeying won’t fix the binding. The door needs adjustment first, then the lock work.
What to do the week you move in
Most people handle this in the first ten days. The order matters less than the timeline.
- Walk every exterior door with a locksmith. Front, back, side, basement walkout, garage entry, any patio slider with a hardware lock. Note which ones turn cleanly and which fight you.
- Make a list of every keyed access point. Mailbox locks count. Detached shed locks count. The padlock on a backyard gate counts if you actually want to control who comes through.
- Decide which locks become “house key” (all keyed alike to one master) and which stay separate. Most families want every exterior door on one key. Some prefer the basement on a separate key for renters or in-laws.
- Replace any smart lock accounts the previous owner controlled. Reset to factory, set up under your own credentials, audit access permissions before you trust them.
- Update any property management or HOA records that need a key on file. Some condos in Silver Spring and Greenbelt require this.
That’s the whole sequence. It’s not dramatic. It’s the thing that lets you stop wondering who else can walk in.
FAQ
Can I rekey my own locks with a DIY kit from a hardware store?
You can buy rekey kits for some brands. The kits are brand-specific and only work if your locks are exactly the model the kit supports. Most homeowners find that one or two of their locks fit and the rest don’t, and they end up calling a locksmith for the remainder. A walk-through with a pro covers everything in one visit and includes hardware that the kits don’t address.
How long does a full house rekey take?
For a standard single-family home with four to six keyed entry points, plan on about an hour of work onsite. Larger homes with more doors, mortise locks, or smart hardware can run longer. The locksmith should give you an estimate at the start of the visit so you know what you’re looking at.
Should I rekey if I’m just renting, not buying?
Talk to your landlord first. In Maryland, tenants generally need landlord permission to alter locks, and the landlord typically wants a key on file. Many landlords will agree to a rekey at the tenant’s request, especially if the unit just turned over from a previous renter. Putting it in writing protects everyone.
What about the garage door opener?
A keyed garage entry door rekeys like any other lock. The motorized overhead opener is a separate system. Reprogramming the remotes and access codes is its own task. If the previous owner had a keypad on the outside of the garage, change that code before you move the first box in.
Closing
The new keys are the start of treating the house as actually yours. Until they’re cut, you’re still living on the previous owner’s access list. Most of the people on that list are harmless. You still don’t want to be on it.
If you’re settling into a new place anywhere in Montgomery County or Prince George’s County and want a locksmith to walk every door with you, call (301) 888-5152 to talk to our team, or request a quote through our contact form and we’ll get back to you.