What each one changes
| Rekey | Replace | |
|---|---|---|
| What changes | The pins inside the cylinder, and the key | The whole lock |
| Old keys | Stop working | Stop working |
| Your hardware | Stays: same look, same finish | New lock, new look if you want one |
| Security level | The same as before | Can go up: a stronger deadbolt, a high-security cylinder, a smart lock |
| Fixes a lock that sticks or won’t latch | No | Yes |
| Usual reason | New home, lost key, tenant or staff change | Wear, damage, a break-in, an upgrade |
| Service page | House lock rekeying | House lock replacement |
Rekey when
- You just moved in and don’t know who still has a key.
- A key was lost or stolen, and the locks themselves are fine.
- A tenant, roommate or employee moved on.
- You want every door on one key and the locks share a keyway.
Replace when
- The lock sticks, grinds, won’t latch, or the key only turns at an angle.
- The lock or door was damaged in a break-in. For a business, see business locks after a break-in.
- You want more security than the current lock offers.
- You want a keypad or app lock. See smart lock installation.
When to do both
A common visit: replace the front deadbolt with a stronger one, then rekey the back door and garage entry to the same new key. You get the upgrade where it matters and one key for the house.
For a business
The same logic applies, with two additions: commercial locks often take interchangeable cores that can be changed without replacing the whole lock, and a master key system lets managers open every door while staff keys open only theirs. See business lock rekey and business lock replacement.
Not sure which you need?
Call (301) 888-5152 and describe the locks and what happened. We’ll tell you on the call which makes sense and quote it, and if the technician finds a lock that rekeying won’t fix, we explain why and price the change before doing it. What affects the cost of rekeying a house covers the details.
Questions
Does rekeying make my lock less secure?
No. It changes which key works, not how strong the lock is.
Does rekeying cost less than replacing?
Usually, because the hardware stays. Replacing costs more but fixes worn locks and can raise security.
Can I rekey a lock after a break-in?
If the lock wasn’t damaged, yes. If it was forced, replace it, and check the door and strike plate too.