When a tenant moves out, every key they had, and every copy they made, still fits your door. You can rekey or replace locks between tenants, and both stop old keys from working. Rekeying keeps the lock you have and changes the inside so it takes a new key. Replacing swaps in new hardware. For most rental turnovers in Prince George’s County and DC, rekeying is enough, but there are clear cases where a new lock is the better call.
Here is how to tell which one your unit needs, with a few situations landlords and property managers in our area run into often.
What rekeying actually changes
A standard pin tumbler lock has a set of small pins inside the cylinder. The cuts on a key lift those pins to exactly the right height so the cylinder can turn. When a locksmith rekeys a lock, they take the cylinder apart and swap the pins for a new set that matches a new key. The lock body and handle stay in place. The old key no longer lines up with the pins, so it will not turn the lock.
That is why rekeying suits most turnovers. The lock itself is usually fine. The problem is that you have no way of knowing how many copies of the old key are out there. Former tenants, their roommates, a dog walker or a contractor from two years ago may all have one.
Rekeying also lets you set several doors to work with one key. If the front and back doors of your rental each take a different key, they can usually be rekeyed to a single new key, provided the locks share the same keyway.
When replacing the lock makes more sense
Rekeying only helps if the lock is in good working order. Replace instead when:
- The lock is worn or damaged. A deadbolt that sticks or a cylinder that needs the key jiggled will keep failing after a rekey. New pins will not fix a worn mechanism.
- The previous tenant changed the hardware. Sometimes you find a lock you did not install, and you may not be able to account for its keys. Swapping it out puts the door back on hardware you know.
- You want a stronger lock. A turnover is a natural time to move from a basic deadbolt to a higher-grade one, or to add a deadbolt to a door that only has a knob lock.
- The door has mismatched brands. Locks from different manufacturers often use different keyways, so they cannot all be rekeyed to one key. Replacing one or two of them can get the whole unit on a single key.
Our technicians look at the lock before recommending anything, and we explain both options before work starts. If a rekey will do the job, we will tell you.
Rekey or replace locks between tenants: local situations
Rental stock in Prince George’s County and DC is mixed: single-family homes and townhouses, garden apartments, condos and rowhouses split into units. A few turnover situations come up again and again.
DC rowhouses with an English basement unit
Many DC rowhouses have an English basement apartment with its own entrance at or below street level, plus a shared rear door or a door between the basement and the main house. Each of those doors needs a decision at turnover. If only the basement tenant is leaving, the basement entry and any shared door they had a key to are the ones to rekey. The interior connecting door is easy to forget, and it is often the one with the oldest hardware.
Older rowhouse doors can also carry original or long-installed locks that are worn from decades of use. Those are good candidates for replacement rather than a rekey, especially if a newer deadbolt was added above them at some point and the two take different keys.
Single-family rentals in Prince George’s County
Prince George’s County requires a rental license for single-family rental homes, and the County’s licensing process can include an inspection of the property. The Office of Homeland Security’s Code Compliance Division runs that program, and its single-family rental licensing page explains who needs a license and how inspections work. Homes in some municipalities, such as Bowie and Greenbelt, are licensed by the city instead. A turnover is a sensible time to check that every exterior door locks and unlocks smoothly before a new tenant or an inspector arrives.
DC rentals and the basic business license inspection
In DC, landlords need a Basic Business License to rent out housing, and the District’s licensing inspection page says rental property providers must obtain and pass an inspection to get or renew that license. Locks are only one small part of a rental property, but a door that will not latch or a deadbolt that will not throw is the kind of thing worth fixing during turnover, not after.
For questions about notice to tenants or what your lease requires, check your lease and the County or District agency that oversees rentals. We can tell you what your locks need. We cannot give legal advice.
If you own or manage property in the area, our Prince George’s County locksmith page covers the towns we serve there.
A simple way to decide
Walk each door before you call and note what you find. That makes the visit faster and helps us give you a clear quote over the phone.
- Count the doors. Front, back, basement, side, garage entry and any interior door between units.
- Test each lock with its key. Note any that stick or need jiggling before they lock.
- Look at the brands. If the names on the locks differ, mention it, since it affects whether they can share one key.
- Decide how many keys you need. One for each adult tenant, plus spares for you and any property manager.
Locks that pass step two can almost always be rekeyed. Locks that fail it usually need repair or replacement. If you want an upgrade, such as a higher-grade deadbolt or a smart lock with codes you can change between tenants, a turnover is the easiest time to do it because the unit is empty.
What to have ready when you call
Because we are opening up and changing locks on a property, we verify that you own or manage it before we start. Have a deed or management agreement that ties you to the address ready when the technician arrives. It protects you and your tenants.
It also helps to tell us the address, the number of doors, the lock brands if you know them, and whether you want everything on one key. With that, we give you a clear quote and an honest arrival estimate before a technician is dispatched, with no hidden fees. Most turnover rekeys are finished in one visit.
If you are also replacing locks that are worn or mismatched, our house lock change service can be handled during the same visit.
Book a turnover rekey
Master Locksmith is a mobile locksmith based in Silver Spring, serving landlords and property managers across Prince George’s County and the wider DC area. We work 8am to 8pm, seven days a week. To set up a house lock rekeying visit before your next tenant moves in, call Master Locksmith at (301) 888-5152.